cover image
When to use what: Methods for weighting and aggregating sustainability indicators

Langues disponibles :

< Parcourir toutes les ressources et collections

Description

Daté : juin 2017

Auteurs : Bingbing Zhou , Jianguo Wu , Jie Guo , Maxwell Wilson , Xiaoyu Gan , Yuanyuan Zhao , Ignacio C. Fernandez

Summary:&nbsp;An academic meta-review of different methodologies that have been used in publications for sustainability assessments, and understanding differences in methodology choices and their strengths and weaknesses. They aim to produce guidance on how to select an assesment method.Relevance to CCRP:&nbsp; Moderate. The paper itself is very technical on some of the methodology of the review itself, but the final 4-step process suggested for selection of assessment methods is extremely relevant to a CCRP audience.

Voir/télécharger

Collections comprenant cette ressource

Frameworks for agroecology assessment

FRN Process - Design

FRN Process - Assess Impact

Ressources connexes

Infographie

Agroecological principles - CIDSE

Summary:Principles of Agrocecology from International Cooperation for Development and Solidarity putting in pl...

Agriculture
Agroécologie
CCRP
Changement climatique
CIDSE
Développement agricole
Principes
Researchers
Students

Guide

The 10 Elements of Agroecology

Summary:  A useful framework produced by FAO As an analytical tool, the 10 Elements can help countries to oper...

Agriculture
Agroécologie
CCRP
Développement agricole
FAO
Framework
Principes
Researchers
Students

Outil

Agroecology Criteria Tool (ACT) - Biovision

Summary:The Agroecology Criteria Tool (ACT) methodology is based on the analytical framework by Gliessman on t...

Africa
Agroécologie
Andes
Biovision
CCRP
Développement agricole
FAO
Methodology
Options by Context
Recherche participative
Research Quality
Researchers
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs
Stephen R. Gliessman
Suivi et évaluation

Article scientifique

RISE (Response Inducing Sustainability Evaluation)

Summary:  Response-Inducing Sustainability Evaluation (RISE) developed by Swiss researchers to evaluate sustai...

AEI for review
Agroécologie
Andreas Stämpfli
CCRP
Evaluation
Francesco Braga
Fritz Häni
Hans Porsche
Matthew Fischer
Methodology
Suivi et évaluation
Sustainability Assessment
Thomas Keller

Outil

SAFA (Sustainability Assessment of Food and Agriculture Systems)

Summary: Sustainability Assessment of Food and Agriculture systems (SAFA). With a view to offer a fair playing...

AEI for review
Agriculture
Agroécologie
CCRP
Ecology
Evaluation
FAO
Methodology
Researchers
Suivi et évaluation

Outil

NaRIA: Natural Resource Integrity Assesment

Summary: The purpose of the NaRIA Score Card is to provide a rapid assessment of the Natural Resource Integrit...

Agroécologie
Assessment
CCRP
Collecte de données
Conception de la recherche
Edmundo Barrios
Fertilité du sol
Methodology
NRI
Recherche participative
Researchers
Students
Typology

Outil

SustainFarm Public Goods Tool

Summary: The SustainFARM Public Goods Tool helps farmers assess the sustainability of their farming system wit...

Agroécologie
CCRP
Evaluation
Farmers
Jo Smith
Methodology
Organic Research Centre
Researchers
Suivi et évaluation
Sustainability Assessment

Présentation

Agroecology: how do we measure its social impact

Summary: Presentation for Coventry University, Centre for Agroecology, Water & Resilience, considering differe...

Agriculture
Agroécologie
Chelsea Marshall
Clare Horrell
Development
Développement agricole
Impact Measurement
Jane Sweetman
Luke Owen
Moya Kneafsey
Paola Guzman
Researchers
Students
United Kingdom

Article scientifique

Analysis of the potentials of multi criteria decision analysis methods to conduct sustainability assessment

Summary: An academic review of different methodologies used to create sustainability assessment tools, focusin...

Agroécologie
Analyse de données
Kerry Kirwan
Marco Cinelli
MCDA
Multi Criteria Decision Analysis
Méthodes qualitatives
Quantitative Data
Researchers
Stuart Coles
Students
Sustainability Assessment

Étude de cas

Assessing sustainability at farm-level: Lessons learned from a comparison of tools in practice

Summary: An academic review of different assessment tools, used on the same farms in Denmark. Tools assessed i...

Agriculture
Agroécologie
CCRP
Changement climatique
Claus Sørensen
Denmark
Evelien de Olde
Farmer Analysis
Frank Oudshoorn
Researchers
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs
Sustainability Assessment

Guide

The Social Return on Investment (SROI) method. How does it work? What are the benefits?

Summary: A description of how to apply the Social Return on Investment (SROI) method in an agroecological cont...

Agroécologie
CCRP
Evaluation
Impact Measurement
Methodology
Monitoring and Evaluation
Policy-Makers
Researchers
Students
Suivi et évaluation
Ulrich Schmutz

Activité

FRN Diagnosis and designing/planning Exercise

A session plan for an exercise to be conducted with Farmer Research Networks (FRNs, researchers and extension...

AEI for review
Agroécologie
CCRP
Experiment Design
Recherche participative
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs

Vidéo

Experiments with Farmers II - What happens to designs?

This video explores the details of the way in which experiments with farmers could be designed, using a variet...

Conception de la recherche
Dave Mills
Emma Burrow
Experiment Design
On-Farm
Recherche participative
Researchers
Ric Coe
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs
Study Design

Webinaire

Designing Right-N Trials with Farmers - Week 2: "Design Details"

This webinar was given to a group of CCRP West Africa Grantees as part of the Research Methods Support Project...

CCRP
Conception de la recherche
Experiment Design
On-Farm
Recherche participative
Researchers
Ric Coe
Right-N
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs
Students
Study Design
West Africa

Guide

Designing Participatory On-Farm Experiments: Resources for Training

A collection of training materials to support the design of participatory on-farm experiment...

Agriculture
Carlos Barahona
CCRP
Conception de la recherche
Développement agricole
Farmer Analysis
ICRAF
Jan Beniest
On-Farm
Recherche participative
Researchers
Ric Coe
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs
Steven Franzel

Guide

Statistical Guides: Concepts Underlying the Design of Experiments

A booklet giving guidance on the key concepts of experimental design. "This guide describes the main concepts...

Analyse de données
Conception de la recherche
DFID
Experiment Design
Methodology
Recherche participative
Researchers
Statistical Services Centre
Students
Study Design

Guide

Methodes Participatives Pour L’amelioration Varietale Du Sorgho Et Du Mil: Description des conditions de réalisation de l'expérimentation

Partie d'une série de fiches d'information et de guides pratiques sur l'évaluation participative des variétés...

AEI for review
Agroécologie
CCRP
Ecology
Eva Weltzien
Farmer Analysis
pearl millet
Recherche participative
Researchers
Savoir local
sorghum
Students
Study Design
Variety Trials

Guide

Methodes Participatives Pour L’amelioration Varietale Du Sorgho Et Du Mil: : Choix du champ et règles d'implantation d'un essai

Partie d'une série de fiches d'information et de guides pratiques sur l'évaluation participative des variétés...

AEI for review
Agroécologie
CCRP
Ecology
Eva Weltzien
Farmer Analysis
pearl millet
Recherche participative
Researchers
Savoir local
sorghum
Students
Study Design
Variety Trials

Guide

Methodes Participatives Pour L’amelioration Varietale Du Sorgho Et Du Mil: Choix de variétés à tester dans un essai de sélection participative

Partie d'une série de fiches d'information et de guides pratiques sur l'évaluation participative des variétés...

AEI for review
Agroécologie
CCRP
Ecology
Eva Weltzien
Farmer Analysis
pearl millet
Recherche participative
Researchers
Savoir local
sorghum
Students
Study Design
Variety Trials

Guide

Methodes Participatives Pour L’amelioration Varietale Du Sorgho Et Du Mil: Choix des conditions de culture cibles pour la sélection de nouvelles variétés

Partie d'une série de fiches d'information et de guides pratiques sur l'évaluation participative des variétés...

AEI for review
Agroécologie
CCRP
Ecology
Eva Weltzien
Farmer Analysis
pearl millet
Recherche participative
Researchers
Savoir local
sorghum
Students
Study Design
Variety Trials

Vidéo

Experiments with Farmers IV - "Farmers are not replicates!"

Replication is often a point of confusion for researchers. Often, researchers conducting on-farm trials will s...

Blocks
Conception de la recherche
Dave Mills
Emma Burrow
Experiment Design
Recherche participative
Replication
Researchers
Ric Coe
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs
Students
Study Design

Référence

Principles of experimentation that farmers need to understand

If farmers take more roles in experimentation then they need to understand the basic principles of how an expe...

Agroécologie
CCRP
Collaboration
Conception de la recherche
Experiment Design
Farmer Training
Principes
Recherche participative
Ric Coe
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs
Savoir local

Article scientifique

Evaluation, Knowledge Management, Best Practices, and High Quality Lessons Learned

A journal article, published in the American Journal of Evaluation, vol 22.This article discusses  evaluation'...

AEI for review
Agroécologie
Evaluation
Michael Quinn Patton
Researchers
Students

Guide

Participatory Research Methods for Technology Evaluation: A Manual for Scientists Working with Farmers

Abstract: This manual presents methods that enable a...

Adoption
AEI for review
CCRP
Conception de la recherche
Crop Management
Development
Développement agricole
Evaluation
Fertilité du sol
Innovation
Mauricio R. Bellon
Mexico
Recherche participative
Researchers
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs
Transfert de technologie
Zimbabwe

Guide

Handbook for Participatory Action Research, Planning and Evaluation

This handbook is available in English, French and Spanish. It is an integrated collection of...

Agroécologie
CCRP
Daniel Buckles
Development
Domain analysis
Jacques M. Chevalier
Participatory Action Research
Recherche participative
Researchers
Réseaux d'agriculteurs chercheurs
Stakeholder Analysis
System dynamics