Assessing sustainability at farm-level: Lessons learned from a comparison of tools in practice
Available Languages:
Available Languages:
Dated: July 2016
Authors: Claus Sørensen , Evelien de Olde , Frank Oudshoorn
Summary: An academic review of different assessment tools, used on the same farms in Denmark. Tools assessed in this process were RISE, SAFA, PG and IDEA.Relevance to CCRP: High. Although the context of the research was unfamiliar, the process of evaluating different tools is one which could, and should, be applied in any context. The review outlines what both the farmers and the researchers liked, and didn't like, about the different methodologies and how relevant and useful they found the results from applying these methodologies to be.
The individual components of the trove are listed below. Click on one to download the file or go to the external url. You can download the full trove below as a .zip file.
de Olde et al 2016 comparing sustainabilty assessment tools.pdf
533 KB
Infographic
Agroecological principles - CIDSE
Summary:Principles of Agrocecology from International Cooperation for Development and Solidarity putting in pl...
Guide
The 10 Elements of Agroecology
Summary: A useful framework produced by FAO As an analytical tool, the 10 Elements can help countries to oper...
Tool
Agroecology Criteria Tool (ACT) - Biovision
Summary:The Agroecology Criteria Tool (ACT) methodology is based on the analytical framework by Gliessman on t...
Journal Article
RISE (Response Inducing Sustainability Evaluation)
Summary: Response-Inducing Sustainability Evaluation (RISE) developed by Swiss researchers to evaluate sustai...
Tool
SAFA (Sustainability Assessment of Food and Agriculture Systems)
Summary: Sustainability Assessment of Food and Agriculture systems (SAFA). With a view to offer a fair playing...
Tool
NaRIA: Natural Resource Integrity Assesment
Summary: The purpose of the NaRIA Score Card is to provide a rapid assessment of the Natural Resource Integrit...
Tool
SustainFarm Public Goods Tool
Summary: The SustainFARM Public Goods Tool helps farmers assess the sustainability of their farming system wit...
Presentation
Agroecology: how do we measure its social impact
Summary: Presentation for Coventry University, Centre for Agroecology, Water & Resilience, considering differe...
Journal Article
Analysis of the potentials of multi criteria decision analysis methods to conduct sustainability assessment
Summary: An academic review of different methodologies used to create sustainability assessment tools, focusin...
Journal Article
When to use what: Methods for weighting and aggregating sustainability indicators
Summary: An academic meta-review of different methodologies that have been used in publications for sustainabi...
Guide
The Social Return on Investment (SROI) method. How does it work? What are the benefits?
Summary: A description of how to apply the Social Return on Investment (SROI) method in an agroecological cont...
Journal Article
Evaluation, Knowledge Management, Best Practices, and High Quality Lessons Learned
A journal article, published in the American Journal of Evaluation, vol 22.This article discusses evaluation'...
Guide
Participatory Research Methods for Technology Evaluation: A Manual for Scientists Working with Farmers
Abstract: This manual presents methods that enable a...
Guide
Handbook for Participatory Action Research, Planning and Evaluation
This handbook is available in English, French and Spanish. It is an integrated collection of...
Video
Experiments with Farmers I - "Why?"
This video introduces the idea of Experiments with Farmers and explores five reasons to involve farmers in you...
Video
Experiments with Farmers II - What happens to designs?
This video explores the details of the way in which experiments with farmers could be designed, using a variet...
Video
Experiments with Farmers III - "From noise to information"
This video gives some examples of how to look at data from on-farm trials in a slightly different way, enablin...
Video
Experiments with Farmers IV - "Farmers are not replicates!"
Replication is often a point of confusion for researchers. Often, researchers conducting on-farm trials will s...
Video
Experiments with Farmers V - "Communicating the design"
Communication is vital when conducting experiments with farmers. This video discusses some of the issues of ho...
Webinar
Designing Right-N Trials with Farmers - Week 1: "The Objectives"
This webinar was given to a group of CCRP West Africa Grantees as part of the Research Methods Support Project...
Webinar
Designing Right-N Trials with Farmers - Week 2: "Design Details"
This webinar was given to a group of CCRP West Africa Grantees as part of the Research Methods Support Project...
Webinar
Designing Right-N Trials with Farmers - Week 3: "Measurements"
This webinar was given to a group of CCRP West Africa Grantees as part of the Research Methods Support Project...
Webinar
Designing Right-N Trials with Farmers - Week 4: "Implementation"
This webinar was given to a group of CCRP West Africa Grantees as part of the Research Methods Support Project...
Video
Options by Context - The Concept
In this short video, Ric Coe introduces the concepts of options by context interactions by describing the more...
Video
Options by Context - The Design
This video discusses some of the issues surrounding the design of experiments when considering options by cont...
Video
Large N Trials - Concepts
These short videos introduce the concept of "large-N" trials. Ric Coe describes them in terms of more common c...
Video
Large N Trials - Practicalities
This video explores the practicalities of running a large-N trial, including how to overcome the bottlenecks o...
Tool
Tools for Development: A handbook for those engaged in development activity
The Tools for Development Handbook produced by CIDT and DFID.Includes a chapter on Stakeholder Analysis (chapt...
Presentation
Typologies: Wealth Ranking in Project Areas
Presentation given relating to the 'Upscaling Best Fit Maize-Legume Technologies Through Multi Environment Tri...
Guide
Typology construction, a way of dealing with farm diversity: General guidelines for Humidtropics
A document containing guidelines for constructing t...
Journal Article
Territorial Development And Local Knowledge Systems: Engaging local farming knowledge through a right-based approach to agricultural development
A paper arguing that the agricultural development efforts should support the practic...
Guide
80 Tools for Participatory Development
A collection of methodologies and tools to be used to facilitate collective action...
Guide
The Talking Toolkit. How smallholding farmers and local governments can together adapt to climate change
A collection of suggestions for activities that can be used to facilitate discussions with farmers as part of...
Reference
Principles of experimentation that farmers need to understand
If farmers take more roles in experimentation then they need to understand the basic principles of how an expe...
Guide
Practical Guides for Pearl Millet Variety Evaluation with Farmers: Identification of varietal selection criteria of the farmers during evaluation of trials
Part of a series of factsheets and practical guides for conducting participatory variety evaluation with farme...
Guide
Practical Guides for Pearl Millet Variety Evaluation with Farmers: Ranking or Scoring
Part of a series of factsheets and practical guides for conducting participatory variety evaluation with far...
Guide
Practical Guides for Pearl Millet Variety Evaluation with Farmers: Open-Ended Evaluation – Qualitative Data
Part of a series of factsheets and practical guides for conducting participatory variety evaluation with far...
Guide
Practical Guides for Pearl Millet Variety Evaluation with Farmers: Pearl Millet Variety Evaluation with Farmers
Part of a series of factsheets and practical guides for conducting participatory variety evaluation with far...
Journal Article
Beyond average: new approaches to understand heterogeneity and risk of technology success or failure in smallholder farming
A journal article focused on the need for different approaches for the measurement and evaluation of options i...
Guide
Designing Participatory On-Farm Experiments: Resources for Training
A collection of training materials to support the design of participatory on-farm experiment...
Guide
Global Community Action Guides
This pack contains three booklets on community-led research created by the International Accountability Projec...
Guide
SAS2: A Guide to Collaborative Inquiry and Social Engagement
A book providing tools and approaches for development projects, with a focus on participatory research. Would...
Video
Presenting Research Results: Adapting to the Audience Part 2 - Adapting to Farmers
A video expanding expanding on a previous resource on adapting the way you present your results to suit the in...
Template
FRN Observation Protocol
This protocol is for an instrument that can be implemented by facilitators of Farme...
Curricula / Training Course
Introduction to models and tools for social networks
Many quantitative analyses in the social sciences are applied to data regarding characteristics of people, but...
Script
FRN RM Session 2: Understanding networks in agroecology and FRNs (recorded presentations and related resources)
This FRN research methods session focused on how to generate research questions about our networks (for exampl...
Video
Collaboration in Research - Research Methods Seminar
In this webinar, given by the Research Methods Support project for CRFS, Lucie Hazelgrove-Planel talks about...
Video
FRN RM Session 3: Making the most of participatory methods in our research
This FRN Research Methods session aimed to follow on from the presentation given by Jutta Blauert at the last...
Video
FRN RM Session 4 - Rapid Experiments
This presentation was recorded for the December 2023 FRN Research Methods Session. It goes into detail about r...